How Does Using A Marketing Agency Compare To Doing It Yourself?

Howdy, cow folk! Today I’m talking about the pros and cons of hiring a marketing agency versus doing it all yourself.

In this blog post, we’ll explore the ins and outs of each approach, discussing the advantages and disadvantages in a way that’ll help you make the best decision for your business. 

From costs and expertise to flexibility and control, we’ll cover all the bases, giving you the lowdown on what it takes to navigate the world of online marketing. 

So, saddle up and let’s ride into our next chapter on revealing the truth about the Wild West of digital marketing! 

How Does Using A Marketing Agency Compare To Doing It Yourself? 

Now, before we get into the nitty-gritty, let’s set the scene.  

You’ve got your business, brand, and ideas, but you’re unsure whether to hire a marketing agency or tackle that marketing mountain yourself. You’re not alone, partner. Many business owners face this decision, and it’s not easy to make. 

To help you out, we’ve rustled up some key points to consider when weighing up your options. 

The pros of using a marketing agency 

A wealth of expertise for half the price 

Marketing agencies are chock-full of experts with a vast range of skills, from design to strategy. When you’re working with the pros, you’ll have access to their knowledge and experience, making your marketing endeavours more likely to succeed. On top of that, you could save a pretty penny, because you won’t need to hire individual experts for every aspect of your marketing plan. With an agency, you’ll have a whole team ready to take your brand to new heights. Outsourcing your content can even save you money sometimes, but that’s a different story.  

You get your time back  

As a business owner, you’ve got a whole heap of responsibilities. By hiring a marketing agency, you can free up some precious time to focus on other aspects of your business. Let the agency worry about the content and take that stress off your plate. Plus, with a team of experts handling your marketing, you can rest easy knowing that your brand is in good hands. This extra time and peace of mind will allow you to concentrate on growing your business and smashing those targets. 

A barrel of additional resources 

Marketing agencies often have access to tools and resources that may be out of reach for smaller businesses. They probably stay ahead of the marketing game and know what’s new. By partnering with an agency, you can tap into these resources and give your marketing a boost, without investing in a bunch of new training or software. This collaboration can help you stay competitive in your industry and achieve even greater results with your marketing efforts. 

The cons of using a marketing agency 

It can be a bit pricey  

Partnering with a marketing agency can be a pricey endeavour. You’ll need to carefully consider your budget and weigh up the potential return on investment (ROI). It’s often worth it, but can you afford it? At Spaghetti Agency we’ve got packages with a range of prices, but if we’re not a fit for your budget, we put you in contact with someone who is because we’re nice like that, and we want you to do well. 

You can’t stay totally in control 

When you hire an agency, you gotta be prepared to loosen the reins a bit. For some business owners, this can be a tough pill to swallow.  

But you’ve gotta think about it like this: you’re bringing in a team of experts to help you out. These guys eat, sleep, and breathe marketing, and they know how to get results. But if you’re constantly breathing down their necks and second-guessing their every move, you’re not gonna get the best out of them. 

Of course, it’s not like you’re just gonna hand over the keys and walk away. You’ll still have plenty of input and control over the direction of your marketing strategy. But you’ve gotta be willing to trust your agency and let them do what they do best. At the end of the day, it’s all about balance. You wanna find that sweet spot where you’re involved enough to feel comfortable, but not so involved that you’re hindering the agency’s work. 

Finding the right fit for you 

There are a lot of marketing agencies out there, so finding the right marketing agency for your business is no walk in the park. With so many agencies out there promising the moon on a stick, it can be tough to figure out who’s actually going to deliver. 

But it’s worth putting in the time and effort to find the right fit for your business. A good marketing agency can make all the difference in the world, helping you to reach new audiences, build your brand, and ultimately drive more sales. 

So how do you go about finding the right partner? Well, first things first, you’ve gotta have a chat with someone at the agency and see whether you get on and they do what you want to do. You can read as many testimonials and websites as you like, but it’s not just about their experience and track record. You’ve also gotta make sure you’re a good fit on a personal level. Do you feel like you can communicate well with them? Do you trust them to represent your brand in the way you want? These things matter, and they can make or break your partnership. So yeah, finding the right marketing agency for your business can take some time and effort. But it’s worth it in the end. 

Maybe you’re thinking you might be better off going solo without using an agency. That’s cool. Let’s talk about going it alone… 

Pros of doing it yourself 

You hold the reins 

When you’re doing your own marketing, you have complete control over every aspect of your brand’s messaging and image. You’re the one holding the reins, which means you get to steer your brand in the exact direction you want it to go. This level of control can be incredibly empowering, especially if you have a clear vision for your brand and want to maintain complete ownership of your message. 

You don’t have to worry about anyone else watering down your message or taking your brand in a direction you don’t want it to go. Instead, you get to make all the decisions, from the tone of voice you use in your messaging to the imagery you use in your ads. This level of control can be especially important for businesses that have a strong brand identity and want to maintain consistency across all of their marketing channels. 

Ultimately, holding the reins when it comes to your marketing can give you a sense of ownership and pride in your brand. You know that every piece of content you create and every message you put out into the world reflects your unique vision and values. And that can be incredibly rewarding. 

You save your pennies

When it comes to marketing, one of the main advantages of doing it in-house is the cost savings. Hiring an agency can be expensive, especially for small businesses with limited budgets. Agencies charge fees for their services, and there may be additional costs for things like ads spend. 

On the other hand, when you do your marketing in-house, you can invest that money directly into your marketing efforts or other areas of your business. 

Of course, there are some costs associated with doing your own marketing, such as the time and resources required to develop and execute a marketing strategy. But for many small businesses, the cost savings of in-house marketing can be a major advantage that allows them to compete with larger companies. 

If you’re feeling overwhelmed or unsure about where to start, there are plenty of resources available to help you. For example, you could try out our Goldmines, where we teach you the ropes of marketing so you can give it a try yourself. This can be a great way to build your skills and confidence, while still maintaining control over your brand’s messaging and image. 

You get to give it your personal touch 

As the owner, you know your business and target audience better than anyone. This intimate knowledge can lead to a more personalised approach to your marketing. At the end of the day, doing your own marketing allows you to be more hands-on with your brand’s messaging and image. That said, we love talking to clients about the message they’re wanting to send, so if you find a good agency they’ll get to know you and write as if they were actually you. Working closely with an agency that understands your vision and values can also lead to a strong, consistent brand identity that resonates with your audience, giving you the best of both worlds. 

The cons of doing it yourself 

It takes more time than you’d think! 

Handling your own marketing can be time-consuming, potentially taking away from other important aspects of your business. We take care of concepts, content production, proofreading, uploading and scheduling, newsletters and social media posts, and that’s just the surface-level stuff! 

Marketing is an ongoing process that requires consistent effort and attention to detail. You need to regularly produce and promote new content to keep your audience engaged and interested in what you have to offer.  

Lack of expertise  

Unless you’re a marketing whizz, you may struggle to navigate the complexities of marketing without expert guidance. If you don’t have experience in marketing, you may find that it takes even longer to achieve your goals. You may need to invest time and resources into learning new skills or experimenting with different approaches to find what works best for your business. As well as that, the ever-changing landscape of marketing trends and best practices can be challenging to keep up with, especially if you’re juggling other aspects of running a business. What’s more, without a team of experts at your side, you might miss out on valuable insights and data-driven strategies that could propel your marketing efforts to new heights. In the long run, a lack of expertise could potentially hinder the growth and success of your business. 

Limited resources 

As a small business owner, you may not have access to the same tools and resources as a marketing agency. You have a lot of other responsibilities and priorities to juggle, such as managing your team, handling customer service enquiries, and keeping up with industry trends. It can be challenging to find the time and resources to devote to your marketing efforts, especially if you’re trying to do everything on your own. In such cases, your marketing might not reach its full potential, or you could end up stretching yourself too thinly. The other issue is that you might not have the budget to invest in the latest marketing tools or technologies that could give your strategies an edge. Ultimately, limited resources could lead to slower growth and a less effective marketing strategy, making it harder to compete with your competitors if they have more resources at their disposal. 

So which is right for you? 

Ultimately, the decision to hire a marketing agency or go it alone depends on your unique circumstances. Here are some questions to help you decide: 

1. Can you afford to hire a marketing agency? If budget is a concern, you may need to consider a DIY approach or look for more cost-effective agency options. (Or perhaps it’s a good opportunity for you to invest in some training and strategy support.) 
2. Do you have the time and skills to handle your own marketing? If you’re already stretched thinly, adding marketing to your plate may not be the best choice. In this case, partnering with an agency could help lighten the load. 
3. Is maintaining full control over your marketing important to you? If so, you might want to consider handling your marketing in-house, as this will let you keep hold of the reins. 
4. Are you confident in your marketing abilities, or do you need expert guidance? If you’re unsure about your marketing skills, it might be wise to seek the help of a marketing agency. 
5. Are you looking for a fresh perspective on your marketing strategy? Sometimes, an outside perspective from a marketing agency can provide new ideas that you may not have considered on your own.
6. What are your long-term marketing goals? Consider whether partnering with an agency or taking a DIY approach aligns better with your long-term objectives, such as increasing brand awareness, boosting customer engagement, or driving sales growth.
7. How quickly do you need to see results from your marketing efforts? Marketing agencies typically have the resources and expertise to implement strategies and deliver results more quickly than if you were to handle everything in-house.
8. Are you willing to invest in the necessary tools and resources for effective marketing? If you decide to manage your marketing efforts yourself, consider whether you’re prepared to invest in the tools, software, and training needed to stay competitive with your marketing.
9. How important is scalability to your marketing strategy? As your business grows, you may find it increasingly challenging to manage your marketing efforts in-house. In this case, working with a marketing agency could provide the flexibility and scalability needed to support your growth. 

There’s no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to marketing, partner. The choice between hiring a marketing agency and doing it yourself will depend on your individual circumstances, priorities, budgets, and preferences.  

We hope this has helped you decide the path you’re taking on your marketing journey, and if you need extra help, shoot us a message. We’re happy to stay completely impartial and give you the right advice for you. We mean it when we say we’re all about no bull; just beef.  

Do You Struggle to Create Content to Generate Sales?

We’ve Created a FREE Online Marketing Plan…

Use our simple ideas generator to help you make better content, over and over again…

Learn More

Tags associated with this article